How to Choose Between an Executor and an Administrator in New York
When someone dies in New York, the state’s inheritance laws determine how their estate and assets are distributed. If the deceased left a will, the person designated as executor or executrix to manage the estate will carry out their instructions. If the deceased died without a will, the court will assign an estate administrator to handle the task. Understanding the difference between executor and administrator is subtle, but important to comprehend, especially when involved in estate settlements.
What Are the Duties of an Executor?
The main duty of an executor is to ensure that the estate is administered according to the will. A will typically names heirs, specifies how property is to be distributed, and sets forth the executor’s powers and responsibilities. An executor has to file the will with the probate court, notify banks and government agencies such as social security and pension funds about the death, open a bank account for estate assets, obtain appraisals of real estate and financial accounts, pay all outstanding debts and taxes, and distribute the remaining property to heirs. The difference between executor and administrator becomes evident in how they manage these tasks, as the executor follows the specific directives of the will, whereas an administrator must adhere to state law.
A good executor will be familiar with New York’s probate laws and understand how the process works. The executor will also be able to work well with lawyers and other estate professionals. Because this is a fiduciary role, the executor must be honest, reliable, and capable of handling complicated matters that may arise during the course of the estate administration. A strong background in business and/or law is helpful, but not necessary.
What Is the Role of an Administrator?
An administrator is a person or entity who takes over the estate when the executor is unable or unwilling to do so. Like an executor, an administrator is a fiduciary who must abide by the law and carry out the duties as instructed by the court. In the absence of a will, an administrator must identify all potential heirs and conduct a kinship hearing to determine who is entitled to inherit. The difference between executor and administrator is further highlighted in how they are appointed and their obligations under the law.
If there is a dispute over who should serve as the administrator, a Surrogate’s Court proceeding will be necessary. The judge may choose between the disputing parties, or appoint a public administrator. The public administrator will be a government appointee and will retain private estate attorneys on behalf of the state. Again, this emphasizes the difference between executor and administrator, as the administrator may face additional judicial scrutiny and processes not required of an executor.
How Do They Get Paid?
In general, both an executor and an administrator are paid significant compensation to perform their duties. The rate is determined by New York law and based on the size of the estate. The money for compensation is taken from the estate itself. The executor and the administrator are usually reimbursed for expenses incurred during the course of their duties. This includes legal fees, insurance premiums, and any expenses incurred in administering the property. The financial aspects also reflect the difference between executor and administrator, particularly in how their fees and responsibilities might be structured differently under the law.
Clarifying the Roles Between an Executor and Administrator in Probate
When a person passes away, the estate they left behind will require careful administration. This duty usually falls on someone close to the deceased, such as a family member or friend, who becomes the executor of the estate. In some cases, a will names no executor and the responsibility instead falls on heirs who must apply to court for letters of administration. Understanding the difference between executor and administrator is crucial, as these roles carry immense responsibility and can be legally complex, but an experienced attorney can help clarify the specific duties and responsibilities of each role.
The Roles of an Executor
The duties of an executor (executrix if female) are quite extensive, but one of the most important is overseeing the administration of the estate through probate court. The court will verify that the terms of the will are carried out, and that the assets are collected and dispersed as directed. In addition, the executor must provide notice to beneficiaries of the estate and other interested parties, pay all taxes owed by the estate, and file a final tax return and annual report as required by law. This role clearly delineates the difference between executor and administrator in terms of their legal basis and authority provided by a will.
A good executor is also able to interpret and clearly understand the will, which may not always be straightforward. Often, the language of a will is outdated, and there are ambiguous or unclear words that must be interpreted. As an executor, it is your fiduciary duty to prioritize the financial interests of the estate and its beneficiaries, and any compensation you receive should be commensurate with the services provided. This ability to act based on a will's instructions further marks the difference between executor and administrator, as administrators operate under a different set of legal constraints.
If you are selected to be the executor of an estate, it is a good idea to name another person as an alternate in case you are unable or unwilling to serve in that capacity. It is also a good idea to make sure you are familiar with the laws of your state in relation to executor and administrator duties and responsibilities.
The Roles of an Administrator
While the responsibilities of an executor and an administrator are similar, there are some key differences between the two roles. Essentially, an executor deals with estate assets while an administrator is in charge of settling the affairs of a decedent who died without a will (dying intestate). The difference between executor and administrator in terms of appointment and authority becomes significant, especially when there is no will guiding the process.
An administrator must be appointed by the court and given letters of administration before being able to handle the estate of the deceased. The person who applies for the position must submit a petition to the court along with proof that they are an interested party (i.e., a claimant of the estate), a letter from the bank stating their balance, a copy of the death certificate, and any other relevant documents that may be required. The court will then interview the applicant to determine their eligibility for this role. The administrator is responsible for settling the estate of the deceased in accordance with state law but will have limited powers as compared to an executor who has all the legal authority granted by law and the terms of the will. This distinction highlights another key difference between executor and administrator, emphasizing the broader scope of discretion available to an executor.
Understanding Executor and Administrator Selection in New York
An estate’s success depends on having a qualified, knowledgeable, and experienced fiduciary to manage it. The executor carries significant responsibility to ensure the decedent’s wishes are carried out and that assets are distributed fairly to beneficiaries. Understanding the difference between executor and administrator is crucial since while an executor can be any person, the best candidate is someone who is responsible and trustworthy. A NY estate planning attorney can help you select the best candidate for the position and help them carry out their duties.
The Difference between an Executor and an Administrator
In New York, the person named as executor in a Last Will must file it with the Surrogate’s Court and appear there on behalf of the estate at various stages throughout the probate process. The court will validate the Will and issue Letters Testamentary, which serve as proof to banks, government agencies, and third parties that the executor has authority to act on behalf of the estate. The executor’s primary tasks include locating and valuing estate assets, opening a bank account to manage incoming and outgoing funds, and maintaining all property until it is sold or transferred to heirs. The executor must also pay any outstanding debts and taxes and distribute the assets to heirs, following the distribution provisions of the Will or New York intestacy laws. Once all debts, taxes, and distributions are completed, the executor must submit a final accounting to the court, which will outline the estate’s assets, liabilities, and distributions and allow the estate to be closed. The difference between executor and administrator is significant here, as the executor operates under the direct guidance of the Will's instructions.
Although the estate administration process can be lengthy, it is important for those appointed to do their job diligently. Mismanagement of the estate can lead to financial penalties and a loss of confidence by heirs, which could prompt legal challenges. It is also essential for an executor to be able to work well with others, as the process involves working through a variety of personalities and situations. The ability to manage these complex interactions highlights another difference between executor and administrator, where the latter may not always have clear directives from a will.
The executor must keep accurate records and provide an accounting of the estate to all interested parties. This is especially important if there are disputes, as a contested accounting can have significant repercussions for the estate. In addition, there are certain circumstances in which a beneficiary can challenge the executor’s decision, which is why it is often in everyone’s best interest to work through issues with the assistance of a skilled NY estate planning lawyer.
One of the biggest differences between an executor and an administrator is that the former does not have to post a bond, reflecting the trust placed in them by the deceased through their will. An administrator, on the other hand, is required to post a bond to protect against any misconduct or mismanagement of the estate. This difference between executor and administrator underlines the varying levels of trust and responsibility as dictated by the presence or absence of a will.
The responsibilities of an administrator are similar to those of the executor, but with additional requirements, such as finding and locating potential heirs. This is particularly important in cases of large estates, as it can take more time and effort to locate heirs who may be reluctant or even hostile to accepting their inheritance. The need to ascertain heirs underscores a key difference between executor and administrator, especially in estates without a will.
New York Legacy Lawyers by Yana Feldman & Associates PLLC
132 32nd St #301, Brooklyn, NY 11232, United States
(718) 713-8080